22 Şubat 2017 Çarşamba

Dignity of a Human Being?



As I was reminded that it was time to write my monthly blog entry, I came up with a long and exciting list that was accumulating in my agenda. Last week, I discovered the amazing visionary artist Lynn Hershman Leeson at the Yerba Buena Center for the Arts in San Francisco. There is another feminist artist named Niki de Saint Phalle (1930-2002) whose work mesmerized me in December and I checked out her memoirs from the library as soon as I landed here. Highly recommended for women's empowerment in the darkness we have been experiencing across the world. I also regularly attend some innovative lectures at BAMPFA where the arts, counter-cultures, and academia’s paths cross (http://www.bampfa.berkeley.edu). 
For the syllabus and the course material refer here:

Mind-provoking debates on counter-cultures in Berkeley continue while Trump’s vaudeville makes the news every day, providing ample daily material to Comedy Central channel and Stephen Colbert as it does to all other humorists. Some professors give extra points to their students to watch some classical documentaries on selected anti-government protests which took place in recent American history. Please take a look: http://bampfa.org/program/hippie-modernism-cinema-and-counterculture

“Hippie Modernism: The Struggle for Utopia”: First comprehensive exploration of the counterculture of the 1960s and 1970s and its impact on global art, architecture, and design can be visited between February 08 and May 21, 2017. The students are encouraged to express their ideas in the freest possible ways, they can attend all the events free of charge including some of the opening receptions and parties. February 10th, I went to a lecture where Jack Hirschman read his poetry and swore a lot to the current president in public. The American law allows for that, as it does the burning of the flag. 

In short, I do have a lot to share from here. However, I received an e-letter from the program director of Middle East Technical University Gender and Women's Studies (GWS) in Ankara, Turkey. The Chair encouraged all the alumni to show solidarity to GWS students and faculty in Ankara University since several of its faculty were expelled overnight under the emergency law in Turkey. In fact, in the first week of February, 330 academics were expelled from their positions across the country. Since August 2016, the number of faculty fired from universities is 4.464. Cumhuriyet Newspaper, one of the oldest and the few independent newspapers in Turkey, reported that Oxford University Professor Timothy Garton Ash (his latest book: Free Speech: Ten Principles for a Connected World) visited Turkey last week and delivered a speech. The visit was for the purposes of support and research. His article about this 3-day-long stay in Istanbul will soon be published in the Guardian.

At the very end of this entry, you can read the graduate students' full statement in English and respond/support them if you like. Here is the highlight

Hundreds of academics in Turkey were expelled by State of Emergency Decrees since September 2016. Head of the Women’s Studies program, Prof. Funda Şenol Cantek was barred from her position by the Emergency Decree 686. Prof. Betül Yarar was expelled by Decree 672. Alev Özkazanç and Gülay Toksöz who signed the Academics for Peace petition like Funda Cantek and Betül Yarar did, were forced to take retirement. On Feb.10/2017, the clash with the police on Cebeci Campus of Ankara University resulted in injuries: the student Maryam Ostadi was taken into custody along with GWS faculty, Assoc. Prof. Emel Memiş, whom I once shared a panel on violence against women in METU-N. Cyprus campus. How ironic and sad!  The statement writers hold the Rector Erkan İbiş and his administration responsible for what has been happening in Ankara University and ask him to resign. They refuse to be silent against these unfair practices. I wonder how many students are without instructors and thesis advisors now. I couldn't find a number probably nobody has bothered to make the calculation. We only know that it is a lot!
The graduate students who prepared the statement below needs support. You can send them emails: (kadincalismalaridayanisma@gmail.com) or facebook messages, see the following link: https://www.facebook.com/solidaritywithacademicsfromTurkey/

Since it is the closest café to the university’s main library, I usually take my breaks in Free Speech Movement Café, known as FSM. The Café honors Mario Savio, who played a key role in the struggle for free speech at UC Berkeley in the mid-1960s. Sometimes it takes several months and thousands of students to make a positive change against the restrictions of free speech as you can read: http://bancroft.berkeley.edu/FSM/chron.html

"The cafe is an educational reminder for the community that the campus freedoms we take for granted did not always exist, and in the democratic tradition, had to be fought for." (one of the many plates on the walls inside where students can see and read clearly!)

I can only hope that the students of our time who are also fighting for free speech will study the lives and practices of role models across the world who fought and won the rights of free speech through different means. Today’s students are standing on the shoulders of these people who had ideals and relentless courage. However, here is the statement which may 'no longer' apply to the system in Turkey in the process and organization of the campus struggles: "in the democratic tradition". Or have we ever had such a tradition, one part of me asks.
 

The Full Text composed by the Solidarity Group of Students and Graduates of Women’s Studies Program:

As the students and alumni of Ankara University Women’s Studies Solidarity Group, we do not accept the unlawful and unfair expulsion of our professors from the academy!

As the students and alumni of Ankara University, Women’s Studies Program, which has been offering graduate courses since 1996 and contributing to the feminist theory and action for more than 20 years, we could not remain silent in such a period of siege against scientific thought and freedom of expression.

We could not remain silent as our professor and the Head of the Women’s Studies Department, Prof. Funda Şenol Cantek has been expelled with an unlawful State of Emergency Decree on February 7, Decree 686 which was recently announced. Our professor Betül Yarar had already been expelled with Decree 672, a similar decree in September. Moreover, our professors Alev Özkazanç and Gülay Toksöz, who took part in the Academics for Peace group like Funda Cantek and Betül Yarar did, were forced to take retirement due to the austere conditions of academia in Turkey. On the 10th of February, when academic freedom and freedom of thought were smashed under the boots of the police forces raiding the Cebeci Campus of Ankara University, a fellow student Maryam Ostadi was subjected to police violence and was taken into custody along with our friend and our professor Assoc. Prof. Emel Memiş. Many public officials who are among the students and alumni of the Women’s Studies Program were expelled from their offices illegitimately just because they defended peace, democracy and equality just like many other professors. Hundreds of academics at Ankara University and other universities were expelled by State of Emergency Decrees since September 2016. Both at Ankara University and the other universities, similar events took place, and many academics have been taken away from universities by the mentioned series of Decrees.

In fact, we know that Rector Erkan İbiş and his administration is directly responsible with this process at Ankara University! During this period, our professors who advocate peace and non-violence were criminalized and subjected to investigation. When they became targets of the hate rhetoric of the pro-government newspapers such as Akit and Vahdet, which declared that gender studies is an institution of “heresy” and “perversion”, the university administration has not only remained passive despite hundreds of complaints, but also imposed limits to the number of acceptances to graduate programs. We recently learned that Erkan İbiş, who has been restraining academic freedom and restricting our living spaces at the campuses, is also responsible for the unlawful expulsions! We ask Erkan İbiş, who is responsible for all the injustice, to resign!

Decrees mean obligatory retirements, courses that will not be opened, students without supervisors, dissertations that are hindered, and a department without a head administrator. Furthermore, they mean that the academics who defend gender equality, peace, democracy and freedom of expression are being discouraged from strengthening these values and sharing them with their students with this purpose. Decrees mean unemployment, precarity, and a life that is deprived of all public rights. They mean the repression of the dream of an equal and free world, and smothering of thoughts that go after this dream. They also mean that police brutality and arrests will end the peace, beauty, and the spirit of life by the use of custody, oppression, violence, fear and sorrow.

We came together in the Women’s Studies Program with our different experiences. As a group of students with different backgrounds, it was only the wisdom and diversity of the idea of feminism that brought us together under Ankara University Women’s Studies Program. We experienced standing side to side without any hierarchy: producing together and acting with solidarity in this department. No matter what happens, they will never be able to destroy our diversity and beauty! They will never be able to break us apart from our teachers, friends, and our campus! We believe that our professors and friends will return, we will struggle for their return!

No one should think that the Women’s Studies Program, which has brought academics, activists, workers, artists and people from other various groups together under the umbrella of feminism in Turkey, and which has encouraged them to produce together, does need a stationary address! Being a student at the Women Studies Program does not mean to produce in an ivory tower, it actually means producing the knowledge of everyday experiences, the knowledge of street and life, and to learn from life outside the academy as well. Knowledge spreads! Life spreads! We are everywhere! As Funda Şenol Cantek, the Head of our Department, has recently stated: “Academy has spread into the streets. And this will be a thorn in their side!”

Ankara University, Solidarity Group of Students and Graduates of Women’s Studies Program